Friday, September 20, 2013

"An awful lot of nyah-nyah-nyah..."

Many of those who have seen the world change in the face of modern technology are worried that the electronically-savvy are becoming socially-stunted. Big-shot reporters, curious psychologists, and frantic mommy-bloggers can't seem to get one question off of their minds: is the internet making us stupid? 

Bill Keller of the New York Times seems to think so. In his article, so aptly named The Twitter Trap, he wonders whether social sites "may be eroding characteristics that are essentially human: our ability to reflect, our pursuit of meaning, genuine empathy, a sense of community connected by something deeper than snark or political affinity..." After setting the permission he gives his daughter to make a Facebook account akin to handing her a pipe of crystal meth, berating a failure to connect while connecting, and making a couple of sardonic comments about the Cloud creating room for more "important pursuits" of entertainment (come on, who even plays FarmVille anymore?), Keller and his slide-rule wielding father seem to have two things in common: a disdain for modern mediums, and a fear for what the wide-spread use of these mediums may mean. "Rapport and real conversation" are being replaced, and our souls are being devastated by the desires of flashy screens and instant feedback. 

However, one of Keller's points seems to get lost in all of the cynicism. His masochistic tweet "#Twitter makes you stupid. Discuss" warranted, in his words, an "awful lot of nyah-nyah-nyah." And it was true. Most re-tweets were nasty ("The subject of new media makes Keller talk like a douche. Discuss"), nonsensically argumentative ("Well, apparently it makes YOU stupid"), and critical ("Looks like old media still doesn't like the Twitter"). However, it begs the question: why were most of his responses so negative? Is Keller right in thinking that genuine empathy is being eroded? Whose sense of pride was being hurt by this challenge on a worldwide, million-user social site? And why?

One answer could be found in a new study conducted by Chinese scientists. Published just a few days ago, this study theorizes that the Internet isn't making us more stupid. Rather, it's making us more angry. A team at Beihan University characterized posts on Weibo, the Chinese equivalent of Twitter, by emotion: joy, disgust, sadness, and anger. They found that angry posts were most likely to be re-posted by others, showing that an "angry emotion could spread more quickly and broadly in the network." 

While this is information that still leaves more to be answered (How does this compare to other countries? What makes angry post necessary to share?), such information can help us avoid the things that worried Keller. That is, it can provide insight as to how to learn to model social behavior on the internet. With the knowledge that it is easy to re-blog negative messages-- whether it be due to psychological magnetism, or ease of anonymity-- the findings of this study can be used to possibly teach future internet "natives," those who are born into the wide-spread use of the internet, how to be cyberspace-cultured and better mannered, making the Internet a more empathetic place.  Maybe if we were all able to interact with one another in a positive and supportive way, it wouldn't seem as if the posts that are being made on social sites are "stupid." Instead, they would simply seem "social." And reporters, psychologists, and mommy-bloggers alike would instead turn to the internet for slightly more applicable matters: "#Syria gives Russia chemical weapons evidence," "#Autism rises to 1 in 50 children," "#Homemade natural detox bath recipes." 

"Discuss."


No comments:

Post a Comment